History of Wales / Long reads

Long read

Iron, Power and Protest: Merthyr and the Rising of 1831

How coal, ironstone and limestone made Merthyr Tydfil the iron capital of the world, the ironmasters and their castle, the debt and hardship that drove its people to rise in June 1831 under the red flag, and the lives of Dic Penderyn and Lewsyn yr Heliwr.

Picture: Cyfarthfa Castle, Merthyr Tydfil, built in 1824–25 for the ironmaster William Crawshay II; photographed from the front lawn in June 2009 · Keith Willoughby, CC0 · Wikimedia Commons

Listen to this long read 20 min · Read by Ada, a Microsoft computer voice

In the first days of June 1831 the ironworkers and miners of Merthyr Tydfil, the largest town in Wales and the iron capital of the world, rose against wage cuts, debt and a court that took the goods of the poor. They took back what had been seized, faced the soldiers at the Castle Inn and for several days held the town. Out of those days came a martyr, Dic Penderyn, a leader, Lewsyn yr Heliwr, and the beginning of the Welsh labour movement. This is the story of the iron that made Merthyr, the men who owned it, and the people who worked it and stood up for themselves.

The iron town at a glance#

1759The Dowlais ironworks is founded
1763The Plymouth ironworks is founded
1765The Cyfarthfa ironworks is founded
1784The Penydarren ironworks is founded
1804Trevithick’s locomotive runs from Penydarren
1824–25Cyfarthfa Castle is built for William Crawshay II
30 May 1831A great meeting of workers on the Waun above Dowlais
2 June 1831The crowds take back seized goods and burn the debtors’ court books
3 June 1831The struggle at the Castle Inn: the soldiers fire on the crowd
4–5 June 1831The workers hold the town and turn back the soldiers on the Brecon and Swansea roads
6 June 1831Soldiers break up the mass meeting on the Waun
7 June 1831Lewsyn yr Heliwr is caught in the woods near Ystradfellte
13 July 1831Lewsyn and Dic Penderyn condemned to death at Cardiff
13 August 1831Dic Penderyn hanged at Cardiff

Coal, ironstone and limestone#

Merthyr stands at the head of the Taf valley, on the northern rim of the south Wales coalfield. Here the three things needed to make iron lay side by side in the hills: coal to be baked into coke for the furnaces, ironstone to be smelted, and limestone to carry off the waste as slag. Water from the Taf and its streams turned the wheels and worked the bellows.

In the eighteenth century the ironmasters came for them. Four great works were founded in a quarter of a century: Dowlais in 1759, probably the first works in south Wales to smelt with coke, Plymouth in 1763, Cyfarthfa in 1765 and Penydarren in 1784. A small upland parish of farms and a church of Saint Tudful grew within a lifetime into the largest town in Wales.

  1. Dowlais ironworks, 1759

    The Guests’ works, the largest in the world by the 1840s.Dowlais ironworks, 1759

  2. Penydarren ironworks, 1784

    The Homfrays’ works, where Trevithick’s locomotive set off in 1804.

  3. Cyfarthfa ironworks, 1765

    The Crawshays’ works; its stone bank of blast furnaces still stands.

  4. Plymouth ironworks, 1763

    The Hills’ works, on land of the Earl of Plymouth.

  5. Cyfarthfa Castle

    William Crawshay II’s house of 1824–25, looking down on his works.Cyfarthfa Castle

  6. The Castle Inn, High Street

    Where the soldiers fired on the crowd on 3 June 1831.The Castle Inn, High Street

  7. Penydarren House

    The ironmaster’s mansion where the authorities held out for eight days.

  8. The Waun above Dowlais

    The common where the workers met on 30 May and 6 June 1831.

  9. Pont-y-Cafnau, 1793

    The iron bridge and aqueduct that carried the tramroad and water to Cyfarthfa.

  10. Hirwaun, five miles west

    Crawshay’s other works, where the red flags were dipped in calf’s blood.Hirwaun, five miles west

  11. Hendrebolon woods, near Ystradfellte

    Where Lewsyn yr Heliwr was caught on 7 June 1831.Hendrebolon woods, near Ystradfellte

  12. Cardiff, St Mary Street

    Where Dic Penderyn was hanged on 13 August 1831; now the entrance to Cardiff Market.Cardiff, St Mary Street

Merthyr Tydfil in 1831. The four ironworks ring the old village on the Taf; the Castle Inn stood on the High Street. Positions of the inn, the castle, Penydarren House and the Waun are close, not exact.

Four great works#

Dowlais was founded on 19 September 1759 by nine partners with £4,000 of capital, among them Isaac Wilkinson, who had worked the iron at Bersham near Wrexham. From 1767 the Guest family managed it, and under Josiah John Guest, who could roll a bar or cut a tram of coal as well as any of his men, it became one of the great industrial concerns of the world. In 1821 Dowlais made the rails for the Stockton and Darlington Railway, and by 1845 it worked eighteen blast furnaces with 7,300 people.

Dowlais Ironworks, painted by George Childs in 1840: chimneys and furnaces pour out smoke and flame while workers load the trams below
Dowlais Ironworks, painted by George Childs in 1840: chimneys and furnaces pour out smoke and flame while workers load the trams below · Picture: George Childs, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

Cyfarthfa was begun in 1765 by Anthony Bacon and William Brownrigg, and from the 1780s it was the work of the Crawshays. It cast cannon for the wars against France, and in 1802 Admiral Nelson himself came to see it. By 1819 it had six blast furnaces making 23,000 tons of iron a year, and for a time it was counted the largest ironworks in the world.

Penydarren was built in 1784 by the Homfray brothers, and it was from Penydarren, on 21 February 1804, that Richard Trevithick’s engine hauled ten tons of iron and seventy men nearly ten miles along the tramroad to Abercynon: the first journey of a steam locomotive on rails anywhere in the world. Plymouth, on land leased from the Earl of Plymouth, was begun in 1763 by John Guest and Isaac Wilkinson and passed to the Hill family, whose iron was counted the finest in south Wales.

Crawshay’s Cyfarthfa Ironworks, painted by Penry Williams of Merthyr in 1817: the long range of the works with smoke rising from the furnaces, seen across open fields (Amgueddfa Cymru)
Crawshay’s Cyfarthfa Ironworks, painted by Penry Williams of Merthyr in 1817: the long range of the works with smoke rising from the furnaces, seen across open fields (Amgueddfa Cymru) · Picture: Penry Williams, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

The fire of the furnaces#

Visitors came from far away to stare at the works by night, when the furnaces lit the whole valley. The Merthyr painter Penry Williams, born in the town in 1802, painted Cyfarthfa again and again for the Crawshays, and his picture of the rolling mill at night, painted in 1825, shows the men at work in the glare of the white-hot iron. Merthyr iron went into rails, ships and bridges across the world.

Cyfarthfa Ironworks Interior at Night, by Penry Williams, 1825: ironworkers under the great timber roof of the rolling mill, lit by the glow of white-hot iron
Cyfarthfa Ironworks Interior at Night, by Penry Williams, 1825: ironworkers under the great timber roof of the rolling mill, lit by the glow of white-hot iron · Picture: Penry Williams, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

The Iron King and his castle#

William Crawshay II, born in 1788, was the grandson of Richard Crawshay, the Yorkshireman who had made Cyfarthfa great. From 1810 he managed Cyfarthfa and the Hirwaun works for his father, and he was the one people called the Iron King. Under him the works grew immensely, and enormous quantities of iron were made and coal raised to feed the furnaces.

In 1824 he had the architect Robert Lugar design him a house on the hillside opposite his works. Cyfarthfa Castle was built in 1824 and 1825 of local stone, at a cost of about £30,000, with fifteen towers and seventy-two rooms, and it looked down across the river on the furnaces that paid for it. The town bought it in 1908, and it has held Merthyr’s museum and art gallery ever since, while the rest of the house was for many years a school. It is a Grade I listed building today.

Cyfarthfa Castle in June 2018: the battlemented front and round towers of the Crawshays’ house, now Merthyr’s museum and art gallery
Cyfarthfa Castle in June 2018: the battlemented front and round towers of the Crawshays’ house, now Merthyr’s museum and art gallery · Picture: Richard Szwejkowski, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Hard lives in the iron town#

The people who came to work the iron came mostly from the farms and villages of Wales, with others from England and Ireland. Welsh was the everyday language of most of them, so that the Riot Act itself had to be read in Welsh as well as English when the Rising came. The work was long, hot and dangerous, and the houses were built quickly and crowded close together, with little clean water and poor drains, so that fevers and later cholera came easily.

From 1829 the iron trade fell into a depression. Prices rose while wages fell, and many families had to live on credit. In some works men were paid partly in tokens or notes that could be spent only at the company’s own shop, the ‘tommy shop’ of the truck system, where goods were often dearer and poorer than in the town.

The Court of Requests#

When families could not pay their debts, the shopkeepers turned to the Court of Requests, the town’s small-debts court. Its bailiffs went into the houses of debtors and took away their furniture and goods to be sold. By 1831 the bailiffs were busy all over the town, and no institution in Merthyr was more hated. The court was run by Joseph Coffin, and his house in the town held its books.

Merthyr had another grievance too. The largest town in Wales had no member of Parliament of its own. The spring of 1831 was the time of the great Reform Bill, and in Merthyr working people, shopkeepers and even some of the masters wanted a voice. That year the town formed political unions of workmen and shopkeepers and a society against the truck system.

Cheese and bread#

In May 1831 William Crawshay announced that the wages of the ironworkers at Cyfarthfa would be cut, and he dismissed eighty-four puddlers. On 30 May thousands gathered on the Waun, the common above Dowlais, in what has been called the largest meeting of working people yet held in Wales, to call for reform and against the court.

The bailiffs had come to take the goods of Lewis Lewis, the haulier known as Lewsyn yr Heliwr. He stood them off, and in the end they took only a trunk, which was sold to a shopkeeper. Next day the people of Hirwaun took the trunk back by force. It was the spark. Across the district crowds began to go from house to house returning goods the court had seized, crying caws a bara, cheese and bread, the bare food of a working family.

2 June: the court’s books burn#

On 2 June 1831 the crowds, led by the ironstone miners of Cyfarthfa, swept into Merthyr. They emptied the house of a bailiff and gave back the goods he held. The magistrates and ironmasters gathered at the Castle Inn on the High Street with about seventy special constables; the Riot Act was read in Welsh and in English, but the crowd stayed. That evening they came to the house of Joseph Coffin, took the books of the Court of Requests, the record of every family’s debt, and burned them in the street with his furniture. Lewsyn yr Heliwr was at their head.

3 June: the Castle Inn#

The magistrates sent to Brecon for soldiers, and on the morning of 3 June a company of the 93rd Highland Regiment under Major Folkes marched into Merthyr to the Castle Inn, where the High Sheriff of Glamorgan waited with the masters and magistrates. Outside, a crowd of many thousands filled the street. A deputation went in and asked, respectfully but firmly, for higher wages and for an end to the Court of Requests. The masters, Crawshay and Guest among them, spoke to the crowd in English and in Welsh and told them to go home. They would not.

Then Lewsyn yr Heliwr called on the people to take the soldiers’ muskets. The crowd rushed the Highlanders at the door, and the soldiers at the windows above opened fire into the street. The struggle went on for a long time. Men fought for the muskets hand to hand, and some of the soldiers were wounded, among them Private Donald Black, stabbed in the leg with a bayonet. The street was cleared at last, but the dead lay in it.

How many died has never been known for certain, for many of the wounded were carried away and buried quietly by their own people. The magistrates’ own count found thirteen dead in the street. The historian Gwyn A. Williams wrote of about a hundred people hurt, a score of them fatally, and the figure most often given, then and now, is twenty-four.

The Merthyr Rising of 1831 as the Victorian illustrator Hablot Knight Browne (1815–1882) pictured it: soldiers and the crowd in the street
The Merthyr Rising of 1831 as the Victorian illustrator Hablot Knight Browne (1815–1882) pictured it: soldiers and the crowd in the street · Picture: Hablot Knight Browne, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons

Four days of the people#

The Highlanders could not hold the town. Under steady fire from the hillsides they fell back to Penydarren House, the ironmaster’s mansion, and left Merthyr to the people. For eight days Penydarren House was the only refuge of the authorities. By Saturday 4 June the rising had become an armed revolt: the workers gathered guns and powder, set up road-blocks, drilled in ranks and carried banners topped with a loaf of bread.

On the Brecon road they ambushed the soldiers’ baggage train and its escort of forty of the Glamorgan Yeomanry, drove them back into the hills, and beat off a hundred horsemen sent from Penydarren House to help them. On the Swansea road they ambushed the Swansea Yeomanry, took their arms and sent them back to Neath in disorder. Messengers carried the news, and strikes and meetings spread into the valleys of Monmouthshire and down the valleys of Neath and Swansea.

The red flag#

In those days the workers marched under red. A newspaper account of the time tells how at Hirwaun two flags were dipped in calf’s blood and carried at the head of the march, and Gwyn A. Williams wrote of banners ‘literally dyed in blood’. It is often said to be the first time in Britain that the red flag was raised as the banner of working people. Whether or not it was the very first, the red flags of Merthyr became a lasting sign of the Rising.

The Waun, 6 June#

But soldiers were now pouring in from every side, and with promises of talks and the sight of the troops the magistrates divided the workers’ counsel. A great meeting was called for Monday 6 June on the Waun above Dowlais, where men from Monmouthshire were to join them. Four hundred and fifty soldiers marched there from Penydarren House. The Riot Act was read, and the Highlanders levelled their muskets, but the order to fire was never given. The crowd broke up, and the Rising was over.

Lewsyn yr Heliwr hid in the hills around Penderyn, where he had grown up. On 7 June he was found in the woods of Hendrebolon near Ystradfellte. Many more were taken, some of them from their beds, and the leaders were sent in chains to Cardiff gaol.

The trial at Cardiff#

The trials were held at the Glamorgan summer assizes at Cardiff before Mr Justice Bosanquet. Lewis Lewis was condemned to death for riot and the destruction of Joseph Coffin’s house and goods. Richard Lewis, Dic Penderyn, a young miner who had been in the crowd outside the Castle Inn, was condemned to death on 13 July for wounding Private Donald Black. Others were sentenced to transportation to Australia or to prison and hard labour, among them Joan Jenkins.

Lewsyn’s life was saved by his own kindness. A special constable, John Thomas, told the court that in the struggle Lewsyn had shielded him from the crowd, and his sentence was changed to transportation for life. In 1832 he sailed for New South Wales on the convict ship John, and on the voyage he taught his fellow prisoners to read and write. He died at Port Macquarie in 1847.

O Arglwydd, dyma gamwedd#

For Dic Penderyn there was no mercy. Two witnesses, James Abbott, a hairdresser, and William Williams, a tailor, both of Merthyr, swore against him, but Donald Black himself, who had seen Dic in the crowd, freely admitted that he did not know who had wounded him. The people of Merthyr were sure Dic was innocent, and a petition said to bear eleven thousand names asked for his life.

Joseph Tregelles Price, a Quaker ironmaster of Neath who would make no guns in his works, visited Dic in Cardiff gaol, became convinced he was innocent, and went to the Home Secretary, Lord Melbourne. With the help of the Lord Chancellor, Lord Brougham, he won a delay of two weeks, but no more. Melbourne would not change the sentence.

At eight in the morning of Saturday 13 August 1831 Dic Penderyn was hanged outside Cardiff gaol, in St Mary Street. He was twenty-three. Four Wesleyan Methodist ministers walked with him, among them William Rowlands, Gwilym Lleyn, and on the scaffold he cried out in Welsh.

O Arglwydd, dyma gamwedd. (O Lord, here is injustice.)

Dic Penderyn on the scaffold, Cardiff, 13 August 1831

Next day, Sunday 14 August, a great crowd followed his coffin through the Vale of Glamorgan to Aberavon, where he was buried in St Mary’s churchyard. Outside the churchyard wall his brother-in-law, the Methodist preacher Morgan Howells, spoke to the people in a scene of great emotion.

The blue plaque outside Cardiff Market, on the site of the county gaol, recording that Dic Penderyn was hanged there on 13 August 1831; photographed in May 2012
The blue plaque outside Cardiff Market, on the site of the county gaol, recording that Dic Penderyn was hanged there on 13 August 1831; photographed in May 2012 · Picture: John Levin, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

A confession across the sea#

In 1874, more than forty years later, a respected Congregational minister, the Reverend Evan Evans, reported that a man had confessed to him on his deathbed in America that it was he, not Dic, who had wounded Donald Black. The man was named as Ianto Parker, who had fled to America for fear of being caught. James Abbott, one of the witnesses against Dic, is said to have admitted later that he had lied under oath. It was a confession reported long after the event, not a court’s finding, but to Wales it confirmed what Merthyr had always believed.

Clearing Dic’s name#

Dic Penderyn has never been forgotten. In 1966 trade unionists set a memorial on his grave at Aberavon, and in 1977 a memorial to him as a martyr of the Welsh working class was unveiled at Merthyr’s central library by Len Murray, general secretary of the Trades Union Congress. A plaque at the entrance to Cardiff Market marks the place of his hanging.

In 2000 his descendants began a legal case to win him a pardon. In June 2015 Ann Clwyd MP presented a petition to the House of Commons; the government answered that a pardon is granted only where new evidence shows conclusively that a person was innocent. In July 2016 Stephen Kinnock MP led a delegation with Dic’s descendants to the Ministry of Justice, and when it said no he promised that the fight would go on. In May 2023 a new petition asked the King for a royal pardon.

Dic Penderyn’s grave in St Mary’s churchyard, Aberavon: a stone cross set up by trade unionists in 1966; photographed in July 2011
Dic Penderyn’s grave in St Mary’s churchyard, Aberavon: a stone cross set up by trade unionists in 1966; photographed in July 2011 · Picture: John Lord, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

What the Rising began#

The Rising was put down, but it changed Wales. Within months the first trade union lodges appeared on the coalfield, and in the autumn of 1831 the ironworkers of Dowlais and Plymouth held out through a bitter lock-out for the right to belong to them. The Reform Act of 1832 gave Merthyr its own member of Parliament at last, and the town’s first MP was the ironmaster Josiah John Guest of Dowlais.

For with the rising, the pre-history of that movement comes to an end.

Gwyn A. Williams, The Merthyr Riots: Settling the Account, 1959

Eight years later the Chartists of the valleys marched on Newport, and the names of Dic Penderyn and the red flag of Merthyr went with the working people of Wales into every struggle that followed, from the unions of the coalfield to the election of Keir Hardie, a founder of the Labour Party, as member for Merthyr Tydfil in 1900. Since 2013 the town has held a Merthyr Rising festival every year.

Reading the evidence#

Much of what happened in 1831 has to be pieced together like a mosaic, for many of the court papers have been lost. The newspapers of the day, above all the Cambrian of Swansea, and the papers of the Crawshay family at the National Library of Wales are the richest sources. William Crawshay wrote the fullest eye-witness account for the Cambrian, and he kept the bills for feeding and housing the soldiers: one roll, marked ‘Riot Expences’, holds 125 papers, among them fifty-five orders sent out from Penydarren House between 3 and 11 June.

Accounts differ, and this long read says so where they do. Some put the struggle at the Castle Inn on 2 June; the Dictionary of Welsh Biography and Gwyn A. Williams put it on the morning of 3 June. The number of the dead is not certain. The red flag is ‘often said’ to have been the first in Britain, because no one can prove that no flag of its kind flew earlier. And the confession of 1874 is a confession reported, not a verdict. What no account disputes is that the people of Merthyr stood together, and that Dic Penderyn went to his death saying he was innocent.

Visiting Merthyr today#

Cyfarthfa Castle, its museum and art gallery and its park are open to visitors, and Penry Williams’s paintings of the works hang there. Below the castle the great stone bank of the Cyfarthfa blast furnaces still stands, the most complete of its kind anywhere, with the iron bridge and aqueduct of Pont-y-Cafnau of 1793 nearby. At Dowlais the old stables of the ironworks survive, and a copy of Trevithick’s locomotive stands by the castle. Dic Penderyn’s memorial is at the central library in Merthyr, his plaque at Cardiff Market, and his grave in St Mary’s churchyard at Aberavon.

The stone bank of the Cyfarthfa blast furnaces, which worked from 1767 to 1919, as it stands today; photographed in June 2004
The stone bank of the Cyfarthfa blast furnaces, which worked from 1767 to 1919, as it stands today; photographed in June 2004 · Picture: Stephen Dewhirst, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons

Written by Ifan First published Last updated