History of Wales / Timeline / Industrial Wales

1833

The great copper smoke trial

Farmers of Llansamlet take the Vivians of the Hafod works to the Carmarthen Assizes over the copper smoke that is poisoning their land.

Picture: The Hafod copper works of the Vivians on the River Tawe, painted by James Harris (Glynn Vivian Art Gallery) · James Harris, Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

In 1833 eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet, east of the River Tawe, took John Henry Vivian and his brother Sir Richard Hussey Vivian, owners of the Hafod copper works, to the Carmarthen Assizes. They charged them with public nuisance from the copper smoke that drifted over their land.

The caseDavid v. Vivian, an indictment for public nuisance
CourtThe Carmarthen Assizes
For the farmersThomas David and the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick
VerdictNot guilty

The copper smoke#

To smelt copper, the ore was first roasted to drive off its sulphur, and the furnaces of the Lower Swansea Valley poured out great clouds of smoke. Sulphur and heavy metals fell from it on the fields around, and at its peak in the middle and late nineteenth century the copper trade was one of the great polluters of its age.

By 1800 nine smelters were at work along the Tawe, and the Hafod, built by the Vivians in 1810, became the largest copper works in the world.

By 1823, 10,000 of Swansea’s 15,000 people depended on copper, and the Hafod works alone employed more than a thousand.

The farmers’ case#

The farmers of Llansamlet said that the smoke had made their cattle lame and unable to eat, with their teeth growing long and over one another, and that the teeth of their horses had turned black and decayed.

One farmer told how, after the Hafod works was made larger, the bones of his cattle grew brittle and lumps came up on their knees.

Led by Thomas David, eleven of them formed a club with William Meyrick, a solicitor from Merthyr, to bring the case against Vivian and Sons. They took it to the Assizes at Carmarthen, outside Glamorgan.

The verdict#

The judge told the court that the hardship of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance that such a charge needed, and the jury found the Vivians not guilty. The brief prepared for their defence is kept today in the Richard Burton Archives at Swansea University.

Science against the smoke#

John Henry Vivian had already turned to science for an answer. In the 1820s he built long flues and condensers at the Hafod to catch the smoke, and in 1823 he printed an account of what had been done.

The statue of John Henry Vivian in Swansea
The statue of John Henry Vivian in Swansea · Picture: Stu’s Images, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

The great scientist Michael Faraday visited the Hafod works in 1819 and studied the pollution at Swansea. In 1826 he wrote to Vivian that he was particularly anxious to see his ‘magnificent flue’.

Vivian himself was a Fellow of the Royal Society, and the mineral vivianite is named after him. From 1832 until his death in 1855 he sat in Parliament for the Swansea district.

The valley after copper#

The copper smoke went on for many years, and the industry left the valley a legacy of spoiled land and water. Yet the works lasted long: the last rolling mills at Hafod-Morfa closed only in 1980, and the old engine houses still stand by the river today.

The Musgrave engine house and its flywheel at the Hafod-Morfa copperworks today
The Musgrave engine house and its flywheel at the Hafod-Morfa copperworks today · Picture: RobinLeicester, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

Before and after

  1. The Merthyr Rising

    Workers seize Merthyr and raise the red flag. Ten weeks later, on 13 August, Dic Penderyn is hanged in Cardiff.

    The Merthyr Rising
  2. The slate tax abolished

    The tax of 1794 on slate carried by sea is abolished, and the Welsh slate industry leaps forward.

    The slate tax abolished
  3. The Ffestiniog Railway opens

    The slate line from Blaenau Ffestiniog to Porthmadog opens, its loaded wagons running all the way down by gravity.

    The Ffestiniog Railway opens
  4. The Mabinogion in English

    Lady Charlotte Guest of Dowlais begins publishing her translation of the Mabinogion, bringing the Welsh tales to readers across the world.

    The Mabinogion in English

By Ifan Last updated