In 1833 eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet, east of the River Tawe, took John Henry Vivian and his brother Sir Richard Hussey Vivian, owners of the Hafod copper works, to the Carmarthen Assizes. They charged them with public nuisance from the copper smoke that drifted over their land.SourcesRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833).Brief for the defence: copper smoke nuisance indictment ↗Richard Burton Archives, Swansea University, LAC/126/D/1Brief for the defence of J. H. Vivian and Sir R. H. Vivian, indicted for nuisance from copper smoke on the complaint of Thomas David, 1833.
| The case | David v. Vivian, an indictment for public nuisanceSourcesRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833).Brief for the defence: copper smoke nuisance indictment ↗Richard Burton Archives, Swansea University, LAC/126/D/1Brief for the defence of J. H. Vivian and Sir R. H. Vivian, indicted for nuisance from copper smoke on the complaint of Thomas David, 1833. |
|---|---|
| Court | The Carmarthen AssizesSourceRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833). |
| For the farmers | Thomas David and the Merthyr solicitor William MeyrickSourceRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833). |
| Verdict | Not guiltySourceRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833). |
The copper smoke#
To smelt copper, the ore was first roasted to drive off its sulphur, and the furnaces of the Lower Swansea Valley poured out great clouds of smoke. Sulphur and heavy metals fell from it on the fields around, and at its peak in the middle and late nineteenth century the copper trade was one of the great polluters of its age.SourceThe environmental impact of industrialisation in South Wales in the nineteenth century: ‘copper smoke’ and the Llanelli Copper Company ↗Edmund Newell and Simon Watts, Environment and History 2 (1996)The social, economic and legal history of the copper smoke problem and the technology used to control it; the deposition of sulphur and heavy metals from the works was high, and the industry was a major polluter at its mid- to late-nineteenth-century peak.
By 1800 nine smelters were at work along the Tawe, and the Hafod, built by the Vivians in 1810, became the largest copper works in the world.SourcesLower Swansea Valley ↗WikipediaSmelting needed more than three parts of coal to every part of ore, so it paid to bring the ore to Swansea’s coal; the first copper smelter was set up at Landore in 1717; by 1800 nine copper smelters worked in the valley, and Swansea became known as Copperopolis; by 1860 the valley smelted two-thirds of the copper ore imported into Britain; the industry left a legacy of contaminated land and water.Hafod Copperworks ↗WikipediaBy 1823, 10,000 of Swansea’s 15,000 people depended on copper; the Hafod works was built in 1810 by John Vivian, of Vivian and Sons, and in the 19th century was “the largest copper works in the world”, employing over 1,000; the Morfa works was built next door in 1835; the last rolling mills closed in 1980, and the Penderyn distillery now stands on the site.
By 1823, 10,000 of Swansea’s 15,000 people depended on copper, and the Hafod works alone employed more than a thousand.SourceHafod Copperworks ↗WikipediaBy 1823, 10,000 of Swansea’s 15,000 people depended on copper; the Hafod works was built in 1810 by John Vivian, of Vivian and Sons, and in the 19th century was “the largest copper works in the world”, employing over 1,000; the Morfa works was built next door in 1835; the last rolling mills closed in 1980, and the Penderyn distillery now stands on the site.
The farmers’ case#
The farmers of Llansamlet said that the smoke had made their cattle lame and unable to eat, with their teeth growing long and over one another, and that the teeth of their horses had turned black and decayed.SourceThe copper smoke and the farmers ↗South Wales Evening Post, 25 May 2019The farmers said the smoke had made their cattle lame and unable to eat, their teeth growing long and over one another; horses’ teeth blackened and decayed; one farmer told how after the Hafod works was enlarged his cattle’s bones grew brittle and lumps appeared on their knees.
One farmer told how, after the Hafod works was made larger, the bones of his cattle grew brittle and lumps came up on their knees.SourceThe copper smoke and the farmers ↗South Wales Evening Post, 25 May 2019The farmers said the smoke had made their cattle lame and unable to eat, their teeth growing long and over one another; horses’ teeth blackened and decayed; one farmer told how after the Hafod works was enlarged his cattle’s bones grew brittle and lumps appeared on their knees.
Led by Thomas David, eleven of them formed a club with William Meyrick, a solicitor from Merthyr, to bring the case against Vivian and Sons. They took it to the Assizes at Carmarthen, outside Glamorgan.SourceRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833).
The verdict#
The judge told the court that the hardship of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance that such a charge needed, and the jury found the Vivians not guilty. The brief prepared for their defence is kept today in the Richard Burton Archives at Swansea University.SourcesRichard Burton Archives: image gallery ↗History Collections blog, School of Advanced Study, 2021The ‘Great Copper Trial’ of David v Vivian at the Carmarthen Assizes: Thomas David represented eleven tenant farmers of Llansamlet who, with the Merthyr solicitor William Meyrick, had formed a club to indict Vivian and Sons for public nuisance; the judge held that the distress of a handful of farmers was not the public nuisance an indictment needed, and the jury found not guilty (the page dates the trial 1834; the defence brief is dated 1833).Brief for the defence: copper smoke nuisance indictment ↗Richard Burton Archives, Swansea University, LAC/126/D/1Brief for the defence of J. H. Vivian and Sir R. H. Vivian, indicted for nuisance from copper smoke on the complaint of Thomas David, 1833.
Science against the smoke#
John Henry Vivian had already turned to science for an answer. In the 1820s he built long flues and condensers at the Hafod to catch the smoke, and in 1823 he printed an account of what had been done.SourceMichael Faraday to John Henry Vivian, 11 September 1826 ↗Epsilon: the correspondence of Michael FaradayFaraday writes that he is particularly anxious to see Vivian’s ‘magnificent flue’, and asks for his printed account of the measures taken at the Hafod against copper smoke (1823).

The great scientist Michael Faraday visited the Hafod works in 1819 and studied the pollution at Swansea. In 1826 he wrote to Vivian that he was particularly anxious to see his ‘magnificent flue’.SourcesDiscover with Jo: Hafod Copperworks ↗Visit Swansea BayVoices from the past at the Hafod Copperworks, taken from historical sources by Swansea University: the scientist Michael Faraday, who visited the works in 1819; the manager Mr Pooley in 1850; the furnace men’s working day in 1850; the foreman John Thomas in 1841.Michael Faraday ↗WikipediaAmong his practical work, Faraday investigated industrial pollution at Swansea, air pollution at the Royal Mint, and the foul state of the Thames.Michael Faraday to John Henry Vivian, 11 September 1826 ↗Epsilon: the correspondence of Michael FaradayFaraday writes that he is particularly anxious to see Vivian’s ‘magnificent flue’, and asks for his printed account of the measures taken at the Hafod against copper smoke (1823).
Vivian himself was a Fellow of the Royal Society, and the mineral vivianite is named after him. From 1832 until his death in 1855 he sat in Parliament for the Swansea district.SourceJohn Henry Vivian ↗WikipediaBorn 9 August 1785, son of John Vivian of Truro; owned copper mining, smelting and trading businesses in Swansea (Vivian and Sons), Liverpool, Birmingham and London; Member of Parliament for Swansea District from 1832 to 1855; Fellow of the Royal Society; married Sarah Jones of Reigate in 1816, and their eight children included Henry Vivian, first Baron Swansea, and Glynn Vivian; died 10 February 1855; the mineral vivianite is named after him.
The valley after copper#
The copper smoke went on for many years, and the industry left the valley a legacy of spoiled land and water. Yet the works lasted long: the last rolling mills at Hafod-Morfa closed only in 1980, and the old engine houses still stand by the river today.SourcesThe environmental impact of industrialisation in South Wales in the nineteenth century: ‘copper smoke’ and the Llanelli Copper Company ↗Edmund Newell and Simon Watts, Environment and History 2 (1996)The social, economic and legal history of the copper smoke problem and the technology used to control it; the deposition of sulphur and heavy metals from the works was high, and the industry was a major polluter at its mid- to late-nineteenth-century peak.Lower Swansea Valley ↗WikipediaSmelting needed more than three parts of coal to every part of ore, so it paid to bring the ore to Swansea’s coal; the first copper smelter was set up at Landore in 1717; by 1800 nine copper smelters worked in the valley, and Swansea became known as Copperopolis; by 1860 the valley smelted two-thirds of the copper ore imported into Britain; the industry left a legacy of contaminated land and water.Hafod Copperworks ↗WikipediaBy 1823, 10,000 of Swansea’s 15,000 people depended on copper; the Hafod works was built in 1810 by John Vivian, of Vivian and Sons, and in the 19th century was “the largest copper works in the world”, employing over 1,000; the Morfa works was built next door in 1835; the last rolling mills closed in 1980, and the Penderyn distillery now stands on the site.







